19 Pie Would You Rather Questions for Classic Dessert Fans

Pie is one of the oldest and most loved desserts in the world. A warm crust, a sweet filling, and that golden smell from the oven. Almost everyone has a favorite pie story, maybe from childhood, maybe from a holiday table full of food.

But pie fans do not agree on everything. Some people love fruit pies, some people love cream pies. Some want the crust thick and buttery, others want the filling thick and juicy. These 19 fun questions will test what kind of pie lover you really are. Read them, pick your side, and share with a friend to see who wins the pie debate.

1. Would you rather eat only apple pie for a whole year or eat only cherry pie for a whole year?

This is the classic pie battle. Apple pie is warm, soft, and full of cinnamon flavor. It feels like home. Cherry pie is bright, juicy, and a little sour in a good way. It feels like summer.

Eating only one for a whole year is hard. The apple pie would give you comfort every day, but you might miss the fresh taste of cherries. The cherry pie would stay fun and sweet, but you might start dreaming about warm apple slices. Which side are you on?

2. Would you rather have sweet pie at every family dinner or have savory pie at every family dinner?

Sweet pies are dessert kings. Savory pies can be the main meal. Imagine one of them on your table every single family dinner.

• Sweet pie ideas: apple, pumpkin, chocolate, lemon, banana cream
• Savory pie ideas: chicken, beef, vegetable, potato, cheese

Sweet pie at dinner means every meal ends happy. But savory pie at dinner means you eat a full warm meal in a crust. Some people say savory pie is the smarter choice, because you can still have cake for dessert.

3. Would you rather make your pie crust by hand every time or buy ready-made crust from the shop?

Making crust by hand is a real skill. You mix flour and cold butter, you roll it flat, you try not to break it. When it works, the taste is amazing and you feel proud.

Ready-made crust is fast and easy. You open the pack, you put it in the pan, you fill it. It always looks neat and even. But some bakers say it is like cheating. What do you think, is the hard work worth the taste?

4. Would you rather eat hot pie with cold ice cream or eat cold pie with a hot cup of tea?

Both are perfect pairs, but they feel very different. One is a cold-hot shock in your mouth. The other is a calm and cozy moment.

5. Would you rather eat pie for breakfast every morning or eat pie as a late-night snack every night?

Pie for breakfast means you start the day with something sweet. A slice of fruit pie with a glass of milk can feel like a happy morning. Your kitchen would smell like a bakery every day.

Pie as a late-night snack means you end the day with a treat. After all your work, you sit down with a warm slice and relax. Some people say dessert tastes even better at night.

• Breakfast pie: you wake up excited, but lunch feels very far away
• Night pie: you sleep happy, but the morning feels very far away

6. Would you rather bake one giant pie to share with everyone or bake many tiny pies and keep them all?

The giant pie is a showpiece. Everyone gathers around, everyone gets a slice, everyone talks about how good it is. Sharing food brings people together.

The tiny pies are all yours. Different flavors, no sharing, no one taking the biggest piece. You can eat them one by one all week.

Things to think about:

• Sharing one pie makes a great memory with family and friends
• Keeping tiny pies means more flavors and no waiting for your turn
• A giant pie looks amazing on the table, but one flavor can get boring
• Tiny pies take much more time to make and bake

7. Would you rather have extra thick fruit filling with a thin crust or have extra thick flaky crust with light filling?

Some people eat pie for the fruit inside. They want every bite full of juicy apples, cherries, or berries. The crust is just there to hold it all together.

Other people eat pie for the crust. They love the golden, buttery, flaky layers that break apart in the mouth. For them, a thick crust is the best part of the whole pie.

True pie lovers argue about this for hours. Where do you stand, team filling or team crust?

8. Would you rather eat pumpkin pie at every holiday dinner or eat pecan pie at every holiday dinner?

Pumpkin pie is soft, smooth, and full of warm spice flavor. It is the most famous holiday pie in many homes. One bite and you know the holidays have started.

Pecan pie is rich, sweet, and crunchy on top. It is like candy and pie in one slice. People who love it really love it, they would pick it over any other dessert.

At every holiday dinner for the rest of your life, only one of them can be on the table. Choose wisely.

9. Would you rather eat lemon pie after a long hard day or eat chocolate pie after a long hard day?

After a long hard day, your body wants comfort. Lemon pie is light and fresh. The sour-sweet taste wakes you up and makes you feel clean and new.

Chocolate pie is deep and rich. The smooth chocolate filling feels like a warm hug. Many people say chocolate fixes a bad mood faster than anything else.

So after your hardest day, do you want the fresh restart of lemon or the cozy comfort of chocolate?

10. Would you rather eat pie with a fork like a careful guest or eat pie with your hands like a happy kid?

How you eat pie says a lot about you. The fork is neat and polite. The hands are free and fun.

11. Would you rather win a pie-baking contest with a big trophy or win free pies from your favorite bakery for ten years?

The contest trophy means you are the best baker. Your name on the wall, a photo in the local paper, and the pride of beating every other baker. That feeling lasts forever.

Ten years of free pies means ten years of happiness. Birthday pies, holiday pies, Tuesday pies for no reason. You never pay for pie again until you are much older.

Glory for one day or free pie for a decade? This is a tough one for any dessert fan.

12. Would you rather eat banana cream pie on a warm sunny day or eat coconut cream pie on a warm sunny day?

Cream pies are cool, soft, and perfect for warm weather. Both of these are smooth and sweet, but they taste like two different holidays.

• Banana cream pie: soft bananas, vanilla cream, sweet and simple
• Coconut cream pie: tropical coconut, fluffy top, like a beach in a slice

Picture yourself on a warm sunny day, a cold slice in front of you. Which cream pie makes the day perfect?

13. Would you rather top your pie with a woven lattice crust or top your pie with a sweet crumb topping?

The lattice top is beautiful. Thin strips of dough woven over the fruit like a little basket. It looks like art, and it lets the steam out so the filling cooks just right.

The crumb topping is simple and tasty. Sweet buttery crumbs piled on top, a little crunchy, a little soft. It is easier to make and many people love the texture.

Beauty or comfort? The woven top takes real patience, the crumb top takes real butter.

14. Would you rather share your very last slice of pie with a friend or hide and eat it all by yourself?

Sharing the last slice is kind. You cut it in half, you both smile, and the moment becomes a happy memory. Many people say shared food tastes sweeter.

Keeping the last slice is honest. It is YOUR last slice. You waited for it, you dreamed about it, and nobody else even knows it exists. Some secrets are delicious.

15. Would you rather eat strawberry pie at every birthday party or eat blueberry pie at every birthday party?

Birthday parties need a star dessert. For the rest of your life, only one of these berry pies can be the birthday pie.

Strawberry pie is bright red and sweet with a fresh taste. It looks beautiful with candles on top. Blueberry pie is deep purple and rich, with juicy berries in every bite.

Things to think about:

• Strawberry pie looks amazing in photos and tastes light and fresh
• Blueberry pie has a deeper flavor and a beautiful dark color
• Strawberries are a spring and summer fruit, blueberries feel like late summer
• Both make great pie, but only one gets the birthday candle

16. Would you rather eat a deep dish pie that is almost all filling or eat a thin flat pie that is almost all crust?

The deep dish pie is a bowl of fruit with a little crust around it. Every spoonful is full of juicy filling. It is rich, heavy, and very satisfying.

The thin flat pie is mostly golden crust with a light layer of fruit. It is crispy, buttery, and easy to eat with your hands. Some people call it a tart, but the spirit is the same.

More fruit or more crunch? Your answer decides your pie personality.

17. Would you rather bake a pie as a surprise gift for a neighbor or have a neighbor bake a pie as a surprise gift for you?

Giving a pie is a warm feeling. You spend the afternoon baking, you wrap it up, you knock on the door and see a big smile. A homemade pie says you care.

Receiving a pie is a sweet surprise. You open the door, you smell the warm crust, and someone thought of you. No work, just joy.

• Giving: you do the work, but you get the happy smile
• Receiving: you get the treat, but you miss the fun of baking

Which side of the pie gift makes you happier?

18. Would you rather eat peanut butter pie with a salty crunch or eat caramel pie with a sweet drizzle?

Both of these pies are rich and sweet, but they play with your taste buds in different ways. One mixes sweet with salt, the other goes full sweet.

19. Would you rather bring a pie to a picnic in the park or bring a pie to a family gathering at home?

The picnic pie travels with you. You pack it in a basket, you walk to the park, you eat it on the grass under the sky. Outdoor pie always tastes a little better.

The family gathering pie stays home. Everyone is around the table, the pie comes out after the meal, and you watch every face light up. Home pie feels safe and warm.

Fresh air or family table? The last question is yours to answer.

More Would You Rather Questions

• 26 Donut Would You Rather Questions With Irresistible Choices
• 11 Cookie Would You Rather Questions That Will Divide Dessert Lovers
• 38 Cupcake Would You Rather Questions That Are Almost Too Sweet
• 21 Cake Would You Rather Questions for Serious Dessert Lovers
• 32 Pastry Would You Rather Questions With Deliciously Difficult Choices
• 16 Baking Would You Rather Questions for Dessert Fanatics
• 27 Cooking Would You Rather Questions Every Food Lover Should Try
• 12 Chef Would You Rather Questions That Test Your Kitchen Skills
• 30 Restaurant Would You Rather Questions With Delicious Menu Choices
• 22 Bad Habits Would You Rather Questions About What You’d Give Up