17 Checklist Points Charlie Munger Used Before Buying Any Stock, and How Each One Can Help You Buy With Calm and Clear Thinking

Have you ever watched a careful buyer study a shop shelf for a long time before he picks one plain item and walks away calm. Charlie Munger bought companies the same way, with slow study and a short list of tests before he spent a cent. The 17 checklist points Charlie Munger used before buying any stock are a guide built from his talks, his letters, and his long years beside Warren Buffett at Berkshire Hathaway.
Here is the plain fact you should know before you read on. Munger never printed a numbered list of 17 points, and no such list exists in his book Poor Charlie’s Almanack. The 17 points in this article are a synthesis, which is a careful gathering of his ideas from speeches, shareholder meetings, and talks with friends.
I once watched a neighbour buy a costly tool in a rush because a friend had bought one the day before. The tool broke in a week, and the money was gone with nothing to show for it. Munger would have called that a failure of temper, not a failure of luck, because the buyer acted before he thought.
Two real guides sit behind the 17 points, and both can be checked in plain sight. The first is the four filter test Munger named in a BBC talk, which asks if the business is clear to you, if it holds a lasting edge, if its managers are able and honest, and if the price leaves room for error. The second is the 10 point Investing Principles Checklist in Poor Charlie’s Almanack, a book put together by Peter D. Kaufman, which starts with risk and ends with focus.
Read the 17 points slowly, and test each one on a company you already know. The checklist points Charlie Munger used before buying any stock are not a promise of quick riches, and they are a way to think before you act. A calm mind that checks first and buys second will make fewer large mistakes, and fewer large mistakes is the whole game.
The short answer: the 17 checklist points Charlie Munger used before buying any stock are a synthesis of his temper and his method, drawn from his speeches and from Poor Charlie’s Almanack. They ask you to invert the problem, stay inside what you know, weigh risk first, study the people, watch the rewards, and wait for a clear chance. No point in the list is a magic key, and the power sits in using all 17 together before you spend a cent.
Key Takeaways
- Invert first and ask what would ruin you.
- Stay inside your circle of competence.
- Measure risk before you dream of reward.
- Demand a price that leaves room for error.
- Study the people who run the business.
- Ask who gets paid if you say yes.
- Refuse envy and compare only with your own past.
- Use base rates and ask how often this works.
- Think forward and backward to the next effects.
- Weigh every buy against its next best use.
- Wait for the fat pitch and sit still till it comes.
- Act fast and firm when the odds are clearly kind.
- Keep it simple and take one plain idea seriously.
- Check your own wishes before you trust your view.
- Refuse any move that could cause a lasting loss.
- Change your mind when the facts change.
- Think alone and let the crowd make its own noise.
1. Invert First and Ask What Would Ruin You
Munger loved one tool above all others, and the tool was inversion. Inversion means turning a problem around and asking the reverse question instead of the plain one. Rather than asking how to win, you ask what would make you lose, and then you stay away from that list.
The forward question often has no clear answer, and the reverse question gives you work you can do today. A buyer who asks which stock will double this year is guessing, and no honest person can know that answer. A buyer who asks what would wipe out his savings can name three or four clear dangers and avoid each one.
Write the ruin list on paper before you study any company. A ruin list can hold a firm that owes far more than it earns, a boss with a past full of broken promises, and a trade that depends on one short fashion. A list written in ink is harder to forget than a fear felt in the dark.
Munger learned this habit from the mathematician Carl Jacobi, who told his students to invert, always invert. The idea is old, and it works because the human mind sees danger more clearly than it sees luck. A mind that asks what could go wrong first will spot the trap before it steps in it.
Use inversion on your own habits as well as on companies. Ask what daily choice would leave you with no savings in ten years, and the answer will show you the habit to drop. A late night spend, a rushed buy, and a promise made to impress a friend are all small ruins in plain clothes.
Share the ruin list with a trusted friend and ask what you missed. A second pair of eyes often sees a danger that your own hope has hidden from you. A friend who tells you a hard fact is worth more than a crowd that cheers your plan.
Keep this point first on your list, because it guards all the other 16 points that follow. A buyer who removes the ruin first can afford to be wrong on small things, and a buyer who skips this step risks all on one blind hope. Inversion is not fear, and it is the calm habit of clearing the road before you walk it.
2. Stay Inside Your Circle of Competence
Your circle of competence is the small ring of subjects you truly understand, and Munger said the size of the ring matters less than knowing where its edge sits. A doctor who knows medicine can judge a health firm, and a shopkeeper who knows his street can judge a shop firm. A buyer who steps far outside his ring is guessing, and guessing is not a plan.
Munger put this idea in his Almanack checklist as intellectual humility, which means admitting what you do not know. Humility is not weakness, and it is the start of wisdom in his words. A buyer who says this is too hard for me has already made a wise choice, because he has refused a game he cannot win.
Test your circle with three plain questions before you buy. Can you say in plain words how the firm earns its money, and can you say who will still pay for it in ten years. Can you say why the seller is glad to sell it to you at this price, and if any answer is weak, the firm sits outside your ring.
The ring can grow, and Munger grew his by reading for hours each day. A book on a new trade, a long talk with a worker in that trade, and a year of patient study can move the edge a little wider. Growth of the ring is slow work, and slow work is the only honest way to grow it.
Beware the glow that comes from a rising price, because a rising price makes every buyer feel clever. A price that climbs can pull you into a firm you do not understand, and the pull feels like knowledge. A calm buyer asks if he knew the firm before the price moved, and if the answer is no, he waits.
Write down the edge of your ring on a plain page, and keep the page near your desk. A list of five trades you know well is a shield, and a list of trades you do not know is a fence. A fence kept in good repair will save you more money than a clever guess ever will.
The checklist points Charlie Munger used before buying any stock start with this habit of honest limits, and the habit runs through all 17 points. A buyer who knows his edge will pass on most chances, and the few chances he takes will be ones he truly sees. Passing is not failure, and it is the mark of a mind that knows its own size.
3. Measure Risk Before You Dream of Reward
Munger put risk first in his Almanack checklist, and he said all checks should begin by measuring risk, especially risk to your good name. Risk means the chance that a plan ends badly, and the size of the harm if it does. A buyer who measures risk first sees the whole picture, and a buyer who dreams of reward first sees only half of it.
Ask three plain questions about risk before you look at the possible gain. How much could you lose if the firm fails, and how long would it take you to earn that sum back. Could this buy harm your good name, and would you be glad to tell your family about it in plain words.
A good name is a form of wealth, and Munger warned that it can be lost in a single day. A firm that bends rules, hides facts, or treats workers badly can drag your name down with it. A buyer who asks about the name first will pass on many bright offers, and the passing is wise.
Risk also hides in the world around the firm, and a calm buyer looks for it. A new law, a new tool, or a change in what people want can shrink a trade in a few years. A firm that depends on one law or one fashion carries a risk that no bright past can remove.
Do not trust a single bright year, because one bright year can hide a weak base. A firm that earns much in a good year and little in a plain year is a firm with a shaky floor. A buyer who reads five years of results sees the true shape, and the shape tells more than one fine year.
Write the risks beside the rewards on the same page, and let the two columns face each other. A page with three risks and one reward is a warning, and a page with one small risk and three clear rewards is a green light. A buyer who writes both sides thinks twice, and thinking twice is the habit that saves money.
Risk first is not fear, and it is the habit of a mind that wants to last. A buyer who measures risk with care can hold his ground when prices fall, because he knew the worst case before he bought. A buyer who skips this step will panic at the first bad news, and panic is the most costly habit of all.
4. Demand a Price That Leaves Room for Error
Munger said no firm, however fine, is worth any price, and the price you pay decides much of the result. A fine firm bought at a wild price can still end badly, because the price has already eaten the future gains. A plain firm bought at a calm price can end well, because the low price leaves room for error.
Margin of safety is the plain name for this room, and it means buying for far less than the firm is truly worth. If you judge a firm to be worth 100 dollars a share, and you pay 50, the gap of 50 is your shield. A shield that wide can absorb a bad year, a wrong guess, and a slow season.
The table below shows how the shield grows as the price you pay falls. A small gap guards a little, and a wide gap guards a lot, and the math is plain for any reader. Use the table as a guide when you weigh a price, and let the gap speak before your hope does.
| What you judge the firm to be worth | Price you pay | Room for error |
|---|---|---|
| 100 dollars | 90 dollars | 10 dollars |
| 100 dollars | 70 dollars | 30 dollars |
| 100 dollars | 50 dollars | 50 dollars |
A low price is not a bargain by itself, and the firm behind the price must still be sound. A weak firm at a low price is a trap, and a strong firm at a low price is a gift. The price test works only when the first three points have already passed, and that order matters.
Patience helps you find the low price, because fine prices appear when others are afraid. A market that falls can offer a strong firm at half its worth, and the offer lasts only while fear rules the crowd. A buyer with cash in hand and a calm mind can take the offer, and a buyer who spent all his cash must watch it pass.
Set your price before you fall in love with the firm, and write it on paper. A price written in advance is a rule, and a rule guards you when the crowd is loud. A buyer who sets no price will pay whatever the crowd asks, and the crowd asks too much.
The fourth filter in the test Munger named in his BBC talk is this price test, and it comes last for a clear reason. A buyer who understands the firm, sees its lasting edge, and trusts its people can then ask if the price is kind. A kind price is the last gate, and a firm that fails it must wait for a better day.
5. Study the People Who Run the Business
Munger said he would vastly prefer managers with talent and honesty, and he placed people near the heart of his test. A firm is a group of people, and the people decide how the money is spent, how workers are treated, and how plain words are spoken. A buyer who studies the people studies the firm itself.
Read the words of the boss across five years, and watch for plain talk or smooth talk. A boss who admits a mistake in plain words is a boss you can trust, and a boss who blames the weather each year is a boss to avoid. Plain talk over many years is a sign of an honest mind.
Ask how the boss spends the money that the firm earns, and the answer will show his true aims. A boss who builds the firm with care and shares the gains with the workers is a boss who thinks in years. A boss who spends on show and shine is a boss who thinks in weeks.
Watch what the boss does with his own money, because deeds speak louder than speeches. A boss who holds a large share of the firm and buys more when the price falls believes in his own work. A boss who sells while he praises the firm is telling you a plain fact with his hands.
Talk to the workers if you can, and listen to how they speak of the place. Workers who stay for years and speak with pride are a sign of fair rule, and workers who leave in a stream are a sign of trouble. A firm that keeps its people keeps its skill, and skill kept is wealth kept.
A single bad act by a boss can stain a firm for years, and Munger warned buyers to stay away from people of doubtful character. A firm led by a person who bends rules will bend them again, and the next bend may cost you dearly. Character is the one test that cannot be fixed by a low price.
People are the third filter in the test Munger named, and the test is simple to run. A buyer who trusts the people can sleep well when bad news comes, because he knows the hands on the wheel are honest. A buyer who doubts the people will worry each night, and worry is a poor way to own a firm.
6. Ask Who Gets Paid If You Say Yes
Munger taught that human beings react strongly to rewards, and he called this the pull of incentives. An incentive is a reward that shapes what a person does, and a wise buyer always asks who gains if a plan succeeds. A plan that pays the seller well and the buyer badly is a plan to refuse.
Ask who earns a fee from your buy, and how large that fee is. A helper who earns when you trade often will urge you to trade often, and the urging serves his purse, not yours. A helper who earns only when you do well is a helper whose aims match yours.
Ask what the boss earns when the firm does well, and whether the reward fits the work. A boss who gains when the firm gains over years is a boss who will guard the firm. A boss who gains from a short rise in price will chase the short rise, and the firm will pay the cost.
Look at the sellers of the firm itself, and ask why they sell. A seller who must sell to pay for a new home is selling for his own need, and the need says little about the firm. A seller who sells while the firm looks strong may know a fact you have not yet seen, and the fact is worth finding.
Munger warned that bad rewards can make good people act badly, and the warning is worth keeping near your desk. A system that pays for quick sales will grow quick sales, and a system that pays for care will grow care. A buyer who reads the rewards can guess how people will act before they act.
Write the reward list beside the ruin list, and let the two lists talk to each other. A firm where the boss, the worker, and the buyer all gain together is a firm built to last. A firm where one side gains by taking from the other is a firm built on sand.
Incentives are a quiet test, and they take only a few minutes to run. A buyer who asks who gets paid will see through many bright offers, and the seeing will save him from the most common trap in the market. Follow the reward, and the reward will show you the real shape of the plan.
7. Refuse Envy and Compare Only With Your Own Past
Munger called envy a foolish habit, and he said it is the one bad feeling that brings no joy at all. Envy means wanting what a neighbour owns, and feeling low because he owns it. A buyer ruled by envy will chase the gains of others, and the chase will lead him into firms he does not understand.
The market is full of loud winners, and each loud winner can pull you off your own path. A friend who doubled his money in a year will tell the tale at every meal, and the tale will make your slow plan feel poor. A slow plan that fits your own life is worth more than a fast gain that fits the life of a friend.
Envy grows fastest when you watch prices each day, because each day brings a new winner to envy. A buyer who checks prices each morning will feel poor by noon, and the feeling will push him to trade. A buyer who checks his plan once a month will stay calm, and calm is the soil where wealth grows.
Measure your growth against your own last year, and the measure will always be fair. Ask if you saved more, learned more, and stayed calmer than the year before, and let the answers guide you. A yes to two of the three is real growth, and a yes to all three is a year to be proud of.
Munger lived to 99, and his long life shows that slow and steady wins the race. He did not chase each new fashion, and he did not measure his worth against the loudest trader in the room. A long view is the cure for envy, because a long view makes one bright year look small.
Guard your circle of friends from envy talk, and fill it with people who build in quiet ways. A friend who speaks of his own slow progress will lift you, and a friend who boasts of fast gains will pull you down. The talk at your table shapes the choices in your purse.
A buyer free of envy can wait for his own chance, and the wait is the heart of this whole list. The checklist points Charlie Munger used before buying any stock work best for a mind at peace with its own pace. Peace with your own pace is not a small thing, and it is the base on which all 17 points rest.
8. Use Base Rates and Ask How Often This Works
A base rate is a plain record of how often a kind of plan has worked in the past, and Munger urged buyers to start there. A single bright story can mislead you, and a hundred plain cases can guide you true. A buyer who asks how often this works is a buyer who thinks with numbers, not with hope.
Ask how many new shops in your town last five years, and the answer will sober any bright plan. If only one shop in five lasts that long, your plan must show why it would be the one. A plan with no clear edge against the base rate is a wish, and a wish is not a plan.
Look for the plain case before you trust the rare case, and let the plain case set your hopes. A firm that grows slowly for ten years is a plain case, and a firm that triples in a year is a rare case. A buyer who plans on the plain case will be glad when the rare case comes, and a buyer who plans on the rare case will be hurt when it does not.
Munger built his mind from many fields of study, and he took a tool from each one. From numbers he took the base rate, and from science he took the habit of testing a guess. A mind with many tools sees more than a mind with one, and the seeing saves money.
Write the base rate beside your own guess, and compare the two with an honest eye. If your guess is far above the base rate, ask what proof you hold that you are the exception. A proof written on paper is worth more than a feeling held in the heart.
Beware the tale of the one great winner, because the tale hides the nine quiet losers. A book that tells of one rich trader will sell many copies, and the nine who lost will write no books. A buyer who counts all ten cases thinks clearly, and a buyer who hears one tale thinks in dreams.
Base rates are a cold shower for a hot hope, and the shower is a gift. A buyer who uses them will pass on most bright plans, and the few he takes will rest on solid ground. Solid ground is the only place where a long life of buying can stand.
9. Think Forward and Backward to the Next Effects
Munger taught buyers to think forward and backward, which means tracing what happens next and what happens after that. A choice that looks good today can turn bad in a year, and a choice that looks hard today can turn good in a year. A buyer who sees two steps ahead will not be fooled by the first step.
Ask what happens if the firm wins, and then ask what happens if it wins too much. A firm that wins may draw strong rivals, and strong rivals can cut its gains in a few years. A buyer who sees the rivals coming will not pay a price that assumes no rival ever comes.
Ask what happens if the firm loses, and who must pay for the loss. A firm with a strong base can lose a little and stand, and a firm with a weak base can lose a little and fall. A buyer who maps the loss before he buys will not be shocked when the loss arrives.
Think in second and third order effects, which is a plain way to say that each result brings a new result. A new law can raise costs, and higher costs can cut hiring, and fewer workers can slow the whole firm. A chain of three links is easy to trace on paper, and the tracing will show you the true cost of a plan.
Use this habit on your own life as well as on firms, because your life is the larger firm. A buy that ties up all your savings can block a better chance next year, and a blocked chance is a cost you cannot see today. A buyer who leaves room for the next chance keeps his options open, and open options are a form of wealth.
Write the chain of effects on a page, with each link on its own line. A chain that ends in a wide field of gains is a chain worth following, and a chain that ends in a narrow trap is a chain to avoid. A page with three links is a small price for a clear mind.
Forward and backward thought is part of analytic rigor in the Almanack checklist, and it is a skill that grows with use. A buyer who traces effects each week will soon do it without effort, and the habit will guard every buy he makes. Clear thought is the cheapest shield a buyer can own.
10. Weigh Every Buy Against Its Next Best Use
Every sum you spend on one firm is a sum you cannot spend on another, and Munger called this the rule of opportunity cost. Opportunity cost means the best other use of the same money, and a wise buyer always names it. A buy that beats its next best use is a good buy, and a buy that loses to it is a poor buy.
Name the next best use before you buy, and write it beside the firm you like. The next best use may be a plain savings plan, a share in a firm you already own, or cash kept for a better day. A named rival keeps your hopes honest, and an unnamed rival lets your hopes run wild.
Munger said that proper use of money is the first job of a buyer, and he kept this rule at the heart of his list. A buyer with ten good ideas and money for three must pick the three best, and the picking is the real work. A buyer who buys all ten has not chosen at all, and his money is spread too thin to work.
Ask if the new firm is better than the best firm you already own, and the answer will guide your hand. If the new firm is weaker, the money is better left where it is, and the waiting will cost you nothing. If the new firm is stronger, the move is clear, and the money can shift with a calm mind.
Cash kept for a better day is not lazy money, and it is a tool that waits for its moment. A buyer with cash in hand can take a fine offer when fear rules the crowd, and a buyer with no cash must watch the offer pass. A pile of cash is a quiet strength, and the strength shows only when it is needed.
Review your holdings once each season, and ask if each one still beats its next best use. A firm that has grown weak should make room for a stronger one, and a firm that has grown strong should be left to grow. A seasonal review keeps the money where it works hardest, and the work shows in the years.
This point turns a list of good firms into a short list of best firms, and the short list is where the money belongs. A buyer who weighs each buy against its rival will own few firms, and the few will be ones he knows well. Few and known beats many and guessed, and that is the plain rule of this point.
11. Wait for the Fat Pitch and Sit Still Till It Comes
Munger often used the words fat pitch, which means a rare chance where the odds are clearly in your favour. A fat pitch is a strong firm at a low price, with honest people and a clear future, and such chances come only a few times in a life. A buyer who waits for them will strike few times, and each strike will count.
Most days bring no fat pitch, and the wise buyer does nothing on those days. Doing nothing is hard, because the crowd is always busy and the news is always loud. A buyer who can sit still while others rush is a buyer with a rare and costly skill.
Munger said the big money is not in the buying and selling, but in the waiting, and his long life proved the words. A firm bought at a kind price and held for years can grow far beyond the gain of ten quick trades. Waiting is not laziness, and it is the work of a patient mind.
A study by University College London found that a new habit takes about 66 days to feel natural, and the range runs from 18 days to 254 days. That number shows that patience is a habit like any other, and it grows stronger with each week you keep it. A buyer who practices waiting for two months will find the third month far easier.
Fill the waiting time with study, and let each quiet week add a page to your knowledge. A buyer who reads while he waits will know the fat pitch when it comes, and a buyer who frets while he waits will miss it. Study is the friend of patience, and the two grow best side by side.
I learned this lesson the slow way, by rushing into a bright offer that faded in a single season. The loss was small, yet the lesson was large, and it taught me that a missed chance costs nothing while a rushed buy can cost much. A calm wait would have saved the money, and the memory of that wait now guards my purse.
Patience sits near the heart of the Almanack checklist, and it asks you to resist the natural human urge to act. A buyer who waits for the fat pitch will own few firms, and the few will be bought at kind prices. Few and kind is the whole art of this point, and the art rewards those who can sit still.
12. Act Fast and Firm When the Odds Are Clearly Kind
Patience has a twin, and the twin is decisiveness, which means acting with firm resolve when the moment comes. A buyer who waits for years and then freezes at the fat pitch has wasted the whole wait. Munger taught that when the odds are greatly in your favour, you must act with conviction, and the act must be firm.
A fat pitch does not wait, and the low price can vanish in days. A buyer who has done the study in advance can act in hours, because the work is already done. A buyer who starts the study when the price falls will be too late, and the chance will pass to a readier mind.
Firm action means buying enough for the gain to matter, and a tiny buy is a wasted chance. A buyer who risks only a coin on a great chance has not truly acted, and the gain will be too small to change his life. A firm buy is not a wild buy, and it is a sized buy that fits the strength of the case.
Do not confuse firm action with haste, because haste skips the checks and firm action follows them. A hasty buyer acts before he studies, and a firm buyer acts after he studies. The difference is the whole list you have just read, and the list is the line between the two.
Prepare the money in advance, so the act can be quick when the day comes. A buyer with cash in hand and a written price can move in a single morning, and a buyer who must sell other things first will miss the moment. Readiness is the quiet partner of decisiveness, and the two must walk together.
Tell a trusted friend your plan in advance, and let the friend hold you to it. A plan spoken aloud is harder to drop when fear arrives, and a friend who reminds you of your own words is a gift. A buyer who stands alone with his plan must have a strong will, and a spoken plan lends him strength.
Decisiveness closes the circle that patience opens, and the two together form the rhythm of Munger’s way. Wait long, study well, and then act firm when the odds are kind, and the rhythm will serve you for a lifetime. A buyer who masters this rhythm will buy rarely, and each buy will count.
13. Keep It Simple and Take One Plain Idea Seriously
Munger said to take a simple idea and take it seriously, and those few words hold much of his way. A simple idea is one you can say in a single plain sentence, and a serious mind keeps it for years. A buyer with one simple idea kept for a decade will beat a buyer with a hundred clever ideas kept for a week.
Simple does not mean shallow, and the simplest ideas are often the hardest to keep. Saving a share of pay each month, buying only what you understand, and waiting for a kind price are all simple ideas. Each one is easy to say and hard to keep, and the keeping is where the wealth grows.
Beware the clever plan with many moving parts, because each part can break. A plan that needs ten things to go right will fail when one thing goes wrong, and the failure will cost you dearly. A plan that needs one thing to go right is a plan you can guard, and the guarding is simple work.
Focus sits last in the Almanack checklist, and it asks you to keep your eye on the main thing. A buyer who chases each new fashion will own a pile of small guesses and no clear plan. A buyer who holds one clear aim will own few firms, and each one will serve the aim.
Write your one simple idea on a card, and keep the card where you see it each morning. A card that reads buy only what you understand and wait for a kind price is a rule for a lifetime. A rule seen each day becomes a habit, and a habit kept for years becomes a fortune.
Teach the simple idea to your children, and let them hear it in plain words. A child who learns to buy only what he understands will grow into an adult who avoids traps with ease. A simple idea taught young is a gift that guards a whole family for life.
The checklist points Charlie Munger used before buying any stock are simple at their core, and the core is this point. A buyer who keeps one plain idea and takes it seriously has already learned the hardest lesson in this list. Simple kept beats clever dropped, and that is the plain rule to carry home.
14. Check Your Own Wishes Before You Trust Your View
Munger spent years studying the ways the human mind fools itself, and he gave a famous talk on the psychology of human misjudgment. The mind loves its own wishes, and it will bend facts to fit what it wants to be true. A buyer who checks his own wishes first will see the firm as it is, and a buyer who skips this step will see the firm as he wishes it to be.
Ask what you want the answer to be, and say it aloud before you study the firm. A buyer who wants a firm to be great will read its weak year as a small bump, and a buyer who wants it to fail will read its strong year as a lucky fluke. A wish named aloud loses much of its power, and a wish hidden rules the mind.
Seek facts that argue against your view, and give them a fair hearing. A buyer who loves a firm should read the words of its rivals, and a buyer who doubts a firm should read the words of its friends. A view that survives a fair attack is a view worth keeping, and a view that hides from attack is a view built on sand.
Beware the pull of the crowd, because a crowd can make a weak idea feel strong. A firm praised by all may still be weak, and a firm scorned by all may still be strong. The only test that matters is your own calm study, and the study must stand alone.
Beware the pull of the first number you hear, because the first number can anchor your whole view. A firm first priced at a high sum will feel cheap at a lower sum, even when the lower sum is still too high. A buyer who sets his own value first will not be pulled by the first number he hears.
Write your view and your wish on two lines of the same page, and compare them with an honest eye. A page where the wish is large and the facts are thin is a warning, and a page where the facts are strong and the wish is small is a green light. Honest writing is the best cure for a wishing mind.
Independence of thought sits near the top of the Almanack checklist, and it asks you to judge by the facts alone. A buyer who checks his wishes will think alone when the crowd is loud, and the lonely thought is often the right one. Clear eyes beat loud friends, and that is the plain rule of this point.
15. Refuse Any Move That Could Cause a Lasting Loss
Munger warned buyers to avoid big mistakes and shun a lasting loss of capital, which means money that never comes back. A small loss can be earned back in a year, and a lasting loss can take a decade to repair. A buyer who refuses the lasting loss guards his whole future, and the guarding is the wisest move of all.
Ask what would happen if the firm failed outright, and whether your life could bear it. A buy that risks a sum you need for food, rent, or school is a buy that no gain can justify. A buy that risks only a sum you can spare is a buy you can hold with a calm mind.
Avoid firms that owe far more than they earn, because a heavy load can sink a firm in a bad year. A firm that earns little and owes much must take on more to stay alive, and each new sum makes the load heavier. A load that grows each year will crush the firm in the end, and the end can come fast.
Avoid putting all your savings in one firm, because one firm can fail no matter how strong it looks. A buyer who spreads his money across a few sound firms can bear one failure, and a buyer who holds one firm must bear it all. A few sound firms is a shield, and one firm is a single point of failure.
Avoid the urge to chase a loss with a larger buy, because the chase is how small losses grow large. A buyer who doubles his stake to win back a loss is acting from pride, not from study. A calm buyer accepts the small loss, learns the lesson, and moves on with his plan intact.
Keep a safety pile of cash apart from your buying money, and never touch it for a bright offer. A pile that covers six months of needs will let you hold a firm through a bad year, and the holding is where the gains grow. A buyer with no safety pile must sell at the worst time, and the worst time is when the price is lowest.
A lasting loss is the one danger that this whole list exists to prevent, and the prevention starts with refusal. A buyer who says no to the big mistake will live to buy another day, and another day brings another chance. Living to buy another day is the whole game, and the game rewards those who refuse to lose it all.
16. Change Your Mind When the Facts Change
Munger was ready to change his mind, and he said that a mind that cannot change is a mind that cannot learn. A firm that was sound five years ago may be weak today, and a trade that was dull five years ago may be bright today. A buyer who holds old views against new facts is a buyer who pays for his pride.
Read the new facts with an open mind, and let them speak before your pride does. A new law, a new rival, or a new tool can change a firm in a single year, and the change will not wait for your permission. A buyer who reads the news with care will see the change early, and the early sight will save him money.
Do not fall in love with a firm, because love blinds the eyes to new facts. A buyer who loves a firm will excuse its weak years and praise its small wins, and the excuses will hide the decline. A buyer who holds a firm at arm’s length will see the decline plainly, and the plain sight will guide his hand.
Set a plain test for each firm you own, and write it on paper when you buy. A test can read that the firm must earn more each year and keep honest managers, and a fail on either test means a fresh look. A written test takes the feelings out of the choice, and the choice becomes a matter of facts.
Change is the ninth point in the Almanack checklist, and it asks you to live with change and accept what cannot be removed. The world will not stay still for your plan, and your plan must bend when the world moves. A plan that bends will last, and a plan that breaks will cost you dearly.
Talk with a friend who holds the other view, and listen to the case with an open ear. A friend who sees the firm as weak may hold a fact you have missed, and the fact is worth more than your pride. A mind that listens to the other side is a mind that stays young, and a young mind learns fast.
Changing your mind is not weakness, and it is the mark of a buyer who serves the facts. A buyer who changes his view when the facts change will keep his money safe, and a buyer who clings to old views will watch his money fade. The facts are the master, and the wise buyer obeys them.
17. Think Alone and Let the Crowd Make Its Own Noise
Munger said that only in fairy tales are emperors told they are naked, and the words warn buyers about the crowd. A crowd can praise a weak firm for years, and the praise can make the weak firm look strong. A buyer who thinks alone will judge the firm by its own facts, and the facts will not be moved by applause.
The crowd is loudest when prices rise, and the loudest days are the most dangerous days to follow. A buyer who joins the crowd at the top will pay the highest price, and the price will fall when the crowd moves on. A buyer who stands apart can buy when the crowd is afraid, and fear is when the kind prices appear.
Mimicking the herd invites average results, and Munger warned that the herd is a poor teacher. A buyer who copies the crowd will earn what the crowd earns, and the crowd earns little after its costs. A buyer who thinks alone can earn more, because he buys what the crowd has left behind.
Keep your study private until the work is done, and let the facts speak first. A buyer who talks of his plan too soon will hear praise that softens his checks, and soft checks are a danger. A quiet study kept to yourself will stay honest, and the honesty will show in the result.
Remember that agreement proves nothing, and the only test is whether your study is right. A thousand voices can agree on a wrong idea, and one quiet voice can hold the right one. A buyer who trusts his own work will stand firm when the crowd laughs, and the firm stand is the mark of independence.
Build a small circle of honest friends, and test your view with them in private. A friend who asks hard questions is a gift, and a crowd that cheers is a trap. A private test with two honest minds beats a public cheer from a thousand strangers.
The checklist points Charlie Munger used before buying any stock end where they began, with a calm mind that thinks alone. A buyer who inverts, stays in his ring, weighs risk, and waits for the fat pitch has done the work, and the work is its own reward. Use all 17 points together before you buy, and let the list guard your savings for the years to come.
Conclusion
These 17 points share one plain idea, and the idea is that buying well is a matter of temper before it is a matter of numbers. The checklist points Charlie Munger used before buying any stock ask you to think slowly, check the people, weigh the risk, and wait for a kind price. A buyer who follows the list will buy rarely, and each buy will rest on solid ground.
Munger never printed a numbered list of 17 points, and the honesty of this article rests on saying so. The points are a synthesis drawn from his speeches, his meetings, and the Almanack that Peter D. Kaufman put together. The synthesis is faithful to his way, and his way was simple, which was to avoid stupidity, wait for the clear chance, and act with resolve.
I hope you keep this list near your desk, and mark each point as you study your next firm. You may find that most firms fail three or four points, and the failing is a gift, because it saves you from a poor buy. Pick the weakest point in your own habit first, and give it one small step this week.
Your past buys do not decide your future buys, and your age does not decide them either. Your daily habits decide them, one calm check at a time, and each check is a brick in a stronger life. A buyer who keeps his checks in calm is a buyer who climbs, and the climb is real even when it is slow.
Share this article with a friend who buys in a rush and wonders why the results are poor. A shared list is easier to keep than a lonely one, and a friend who checks with you will grow with you. Talk about the 17 points over a meal, and let each person name the point that guards him most.
A year from now, the list will feel like an old friend, and the firms you own will be ones you truly know. Keep the ruin list, keep the written price, and keep the calm that a patient mind brings. Buying well is not a single leap, and it is a slow climb that rewards each steady foot.
Tonight, before the day ends, take one small step that proves the list is real. Write your circle of competence on a plain page, or name the next best use of your savings in a single line. A year from today, you will be glad you started on this very night.
