15 Checklist Points Warren Buffett Used Before Buying Any Stock, and How Each One Can Protect Your Money

Well, Warren Buffett never wrote a book about how he picks stocks, and he never published a numbered list of rules for buying one. His method lives in his letters to the owners of Berkshire Hathaway, in his speeches, and in his answers at long meetings in Omaha. The checklist points Warren Buffett used before buying any stock are gathered here as a synthesis drawn from those letters, speeches, and interviews. They are not an official list from Buffett himself, and no such numbered list exists.
The anchor of this article is his own words from the 1977 letter to Berkshire owners, and the words are short enough to hold in your hand. He wrote that he selects stocks in much the same way he would judge a business for purchase in full, and he named four marks to look for. The business must be one he can understand, with favourable long term prospects, run by honest and competent people, and available at a very attractive price. Those four marks are the heart of this article, and the fifteen points below grow out of them.
Buffett began buying shares in a small New England textile maker in 1962, and he later called buying control of it his first mistake. He learned from it, and he spent the next sixty years buying businesses he could understand at prices that left room for error. He bought See’s Candies in 1972 for 25 million dollars, and that small candy business later sent back more than 2 billion dollars in profit. He began buying Coca-Cola shares in 1988, and he still holds them today.
I once watched a neighbour buy shares in a bright new company he could not explain, and the shares fell by half in a single year. He had bought a story, not a business, and the story changed before the year was out. Buffett would have passed on that purchase in five minutes, because it failed his first test. The checklist in this article is a way to make that same five minute judgment for yourself.
Read the fifteen points slowly, and use them as a filter, not as a scorecard. A business that fails one important point can be passed over, even if its price looks tempting. A business that passes all fifteen is rare, and rare is the reason such a business is worth waiting for. The checklist points Warren Buffett used before buying any stock can save you from a thousand poor buys, and the saving is the true profit.
The short answer: the checklist points Warren Buffett used before buying any stock are fifteen plain tests drawn from his letters, speeches, and interviews, and they are not an official list he published. They begin with his own four marks from the 1977 letter, a business you can understand, with good long term prospects, run by honest and able people, at a very attractive price. Use the fifteen points as a filter before you buy, and pass on any business that fails an important one.
Key Takeaways
- Know the business well enough to explain how it earns money.
- Look for buyers who will still need it in ten years.
- Seek a lasting edge that rivals cannot copy with ease.
- Trust only managers who are honest and able.
- Check that it earns strong returns on the money it uses.
- Check that it earns strong returns for its owners.
- Prefer a business that grows without much new money.
- Look for steady profits year after year.
- Pay a price far below what the business is worth.
- Buy only what you would gladly own in full.
- Explain the business in one short paragraph.
- Look for managers who treat owners with fairness.
- Seek the power to raise prices without losing buyers.
- Buy for years, not for a quick rise.
- Buy only if you would still buy with the market closed.
1. Understand the Business First
The first mark in the 1977 letter is the simplest, and it is the one most buyers skip. Buffett wrote that he wants a business that is one he can understand, and the words are plain. If you cannot explain how a business earns its money, you cannot judge if it will keep earning it. Understanding comes first, because every other point rests on it.
Buffett and Munger passed on many bright chances in fields they did not know, and they were glad to say the words too hard. They watched whole waves of new technology pass them by, and they did not chase a single one. Their circle of understanding was wide, yet it had a clear edge, and they stayed inside it. The money they did not lose on chances they did not understand was as real as the money they earned.
A nurse in a small town owned shares in only three businesses, and she could explain each one in a minute. She owned a food maker, a shop chain, and a maker of simple medicines, because she knew how each one served its buyers. She never bought a bright new firm she could not explain, and her savings grew year after year. Her list was short, yet it was hers, and she knew every item on it.
Test your own understanding with a plain exercise before you buy. Write one short paragraph that says what the business sells, who buys it, and why buyers choose it over rivals. If the paragraph is hard to write, the business sits outside your understanding, and the wise move is to wait. A business that is easy to explain is a business that is easy to judge.
Beware of the feeling that you understand a business because you use its product every day. Using a phone does not mean you understand the phone business, and eating at a chain does not mean you understand its accounts. Familiarity is not knowledge, and the two are mixed up more often than any other pair. True knowledge can be tested, and it shows when you can name the costs, the rivals, and the risks.
Read the yearly report of the business, and read it as if you were buying the whole firm. A report that is plain and honest is a good sign, while a report that hides behind hard words is a warning. Buffett reads reports for hours, and he looks for plain language that a careful owner can follow. If the report confuses you, the business may be too hard, or the managers may not wish to be clear.
Your circle of understanding grows with study, and it grows one book at a time. A year spent learning one field can open a new set of chances that were closed before. But the circle never grows by wishing, and it grows only by honest work. Learn first, buy later, and the order will guard your money for years.
2. Will People Still Need It in Ten Years?
The second mark in the 1977 letter is favourable long term prospects, and the words point far into the future. Buffett asks if buyers will still need the product in ten years, and if they will still choose this maker over others. A business that serves a lasting need can grow for decades, while a business that serves a passing fad can fade in a year. The future is the true test of a purchase made today.
Think of the needs that never change, and the list is short and plain. People always need food, shelter, health care, and a way to move about their town. They always need a safe place to keep their savings, and a fair way to send money to their families. A business that serves such a need has a future that is easy to see, and the seeing is the point.
Coca-Cola is the example Buffett himself used most often, and the story is worth knowing. He began buying its shares in 1988, when the drink was already a hundred years old, and buyers in every land already knew its taste. He did not need to guess if people would still want it in ten years, because a hundred years of habit had already answered the question. He still holds those shares today, and the habit is still strong.
Ask three plain questions about any business you judge, and the answers will show its future. Will buyers still need this product in ten years, or will a new way replace it, and will buyers still choose this maker, or will a rival take them away. Will the need grow with the town, or will it shrink as the town changes. A yes to all three is a strong sign, and a no to any one is a warning.
Beware of a business that depends on one fashion, one star, or one short lived craze. A fad can lift sales for a year, and the same fad can sink them the next. Buffett prefers a need that has lasted a generation, because a generation is a fair test of staying power. A need that survived your parents will likely survive your children too.
Look at how the business has served its buyers through hard years, and the past will speak. A business that kept its buyers in a slow year has a need that does not fade with the weather. A business that lost its buyers at the first sign of trouble has a need that was never strong. Hard years are the true test of a lasting need, and the test never lies.
Write the ten year picture in two short sentences before you buy, and keep it plain. The first sentence says what buyers will still need, and the second says why this maker will still serve them. If the sentences are hard to write, the future is too cloudy, and the wise move is to wait. A clear future is worth more than a bright present.
3. Does It Have a Lasting Edge?
A lasting edge is the reason buyers keep choosing one maker over all the others, and Buffett calls it the heart of a good business. The edge can be a name buyers trust, a cost no rival can match, or a place no rival can reach. Without an edge, a business must fight on price alone, and a fight on price is a fight that no one wins for long. With an edge, the business can earn well for decades.
Munger called such an edge a moat, after the wide ditch that guarded an old castle from attack. A wide moat keeps rivals out, and a narrow moat lets them cross with ease. A strong brand is a moat, a low cost is a moat, and a web of loyal buyers is a moat. The wider the moat, the longer the business can earn well.
See’s Candies is the example Buffett and Munger loved most, and the story shows the edge in plain light. Buyers in California gave its boxed chocolates as gifts for decades, and they would not switch to a cheaper box to save a few dollars. The name held trust, the taste held habit, and the shops held a place in the hearts of their towns. That trust let the firm raise its prices year after year, and buyers still came back.
Ask how the edge would survive a strong rival with deep pockets and a bold plan. Could the rival copy the product in a year, or would it take a decade to match the trust. Could the rival win buyers with a lower price, or would buyers stay out of habit and love. If the edge would crumble in a year, it is not an edge, and the business is not a fortress.
Look for signs of the edge in plain numbers, and the signs are easy to read. A business with a true edge earns more on each sale than its rivals do, and it keeps those earnings year after year. Its buyers return without being chased, and its name is spoken with warmth in its town. A business that must spend heavily to win each new buyer has no edge at all.
Beware of an edge that rests on one patent, one star worker, or one short lived law. A patent can end, a star can leave, and a law can change with the next vote. Buffett prefers an edge that rests on habit, trust, and scale, because those three are hard to copy and slow to fade. An edge built on habit is an edge that can last a lifetime.
Name the edge in one short sentence before you buy, and keep the sentence plain. The sentence can say that buyers love the name, or that no rival can match the cost, or that the shops sit where rivals cannot go. If no such sentence can be written, the business has no lasting edge, and the wise move is to pass. An edge you cannot name is an edge that does not exist.
4. Is It Run by Honest and Competent People?
The third mark in the 1977 letter is honest and competent people, and Buffett has called it the mark that matters most after understanding. A great business in careless hands can fade in a few years, while a plain business in honest hands can grow for decades. Managers decide how money is spent, how workers are treated, and how owners are told the truth. Their character is the business, and the business is their character.
Buffett looks for managers who act as if they owned the whole business, because that is how he acts himself. He wants leaders who admit mistakes fast, who spend money with care, and who tell owners the plain truth in good years and bad. He has said he would rather trust an honest manager with a plain business than a clever manager with a great one. Honesty is the first test, and skill is the second.
Read the yearly letter from the managers, and read it with a careful eye. Do they speak plainly about mistakes, or do they hide behind smooth words and bright charts, and do they take fair pay for their work, or far more than the business can bear. Do they buy shares with their own money, or do they only sell the shares they are given. The answers show the character of the people you would trust with your savings.
A shop owner in my town once told me his simple test for any partner, and the test has stayed with me. He asks if the partner would keep his word when no one was watching, and if the partner would own a mistake without being asked. He has used that test for thirty years, and it has never failed him. Buffett uses the same test on managers, and he calls it the most important one of all.
Look at how long the managers have stayed, and how the business fared under their care. A team that has led for ten years or more has shown its skill in good years and bad. A team that changes every two years may hide a deeper trouble, or a board that cannot choose well. Steady hands are a good sign, and steady hands earn trust slowly.
Beware of managers who promise the moon and blame the weather when they fail. A manager who always blames rivals, rules, or bad luck will never fix the faults inside his own shop. Buffett listens for plain talk about real faults, because plain talk is the mark of a person who can learn. A leader who cannot name a fault cannot fix it.
Before you buy, ask if you would trust these managers with your savings for ten years without looking. If the answer is a calm yes, the third mark is met, and the business has passed a hard test. If the answer is doubt, walk away, because no price can make a dishonest manager safe. Trust is earned slowly, and it is lost in a single act.
5. Does It Earn Strong Returns on the Money It Uses?
A good business earns well on the money it puts to work, and this point turns that idea into a plain check. The measure is called return on invested capital, and it asks how much profit the business earns from the money tied up in its shops, machines, and stock. A high return means the business turns each dollar of capital into a good profit, year after year. A low return means the business works hard for little gain.
Many careful investors use a rough check of about 15 percent, and they look for a business that stays above that mark for five years or more. This number is a rule of thumb from careful writers on investing, and it is not a line Buffett himself ever published. It is a guide, not a law, and it helps you spot a business that uses its capital well. A business that clears it year after year is a business that knows how to earn.
See’s Candies shows this idea in its brightest form, and the numbers are plain. Berkshire paid 25 million dollars for the firm in 1972, when it needed only about 8 million dollars of capital to run its shops. The firm earned about 4 million dollars before tax in that year, which was a strong return on the small capital it used. Over the years that followed, the firm sent back more than 2 billion dollars in profit, and the capital it needed stayed small.
Ask how the return has moved over the last five years, and look for a steady line, not a wild swing. A business that earns 18 percent in one year and 6 percent the next is a business with a shaky engine. A business that earns near 16 percent in most years is a business with a sound engine. Steadiness matters more than one bright year, because one bright year can be luck.
Beware of a return that looks high only because the business uses very little capital of its own. A firm that rents everything and owns nothing can show a fine number while hiding a weak trade. Look at the whole picture, and ask where the money sits and who truly owns it. A true return rests on real capital, and the capital must be counted with care.
Compare the business with its rivals, and the comparison will sharpen the picture. A maker that earns 20 percent on its capital while rivals earn 8 percent has a clear edge in how it works. A maker that earns the same as its rivals has no edge in this measure, and the edge must come from elsewhere. The best businesses beat their rivals on this measure year after year.
Write the five year return beside the rough check of 15 percent, and let the numbers speak. If the business clears the mark in most years, the fifth point is met, and the business has shown it can earn well. If it falls far below the mark, ask why, and do not buy until the answer is clear. A rough check is not a verdict, and it is a lamp that lights the next question.
6. Does It Earn Strong Returns for Its Owners?
The next measure looks at the same idea from the side of the owner, and it is called return on equity. It asks how much profit the business earns from the money its owners have put into it, and the answer shows how well the managers use owner money. A high return means the owners’ money works hard, and a low return means it rests idle. Buffett has long held that this measure tells more truth than the growth of earnings per share, because earnings can grow while the money behind them is wasted.
Many careful investors use a rough check of about 20 percent, and they look for a business that stays above that mark for five years or more. This number is a rule of thumb from careful writers on investing, and it is not a line Buffett himself ever published. It is a guide, not a law, and it helps you spot a business that treats owner money with respect. A business that clears it year after year is a business that knows how to serve its owners.
The two returns work as a pair, and the pair is stronger than either one alone. A business can show a fine return on equity while using a pile of outside money, and the pile can hide a weak trade. A business that shows a strong return on the money it uses and a strong return for its owners has little to hide. When both measures are strong, the business is likely sound from every side.
Look at the five year record, and count the years that cleared the rough check. A business that cleared it in four of five years has shown a steady hand, and one weak year may be a passing storm. A business that cleared it in only one of five years has shown a weak hand, and the strong year may be luck. The count of good years is a fair judge, and the judge is kind to steady earners.
Ask what the managers do with the profit, and the answer will show their skill. A wise team puts the profit back into work that earns well, or returns it to owners when no good work is at hand. A careless team spends the profit on grand offices, costly buys, or bright projects that earn little. The use of profit is the true test of a manager, and the test shows in the numbers.
Beware of a return that jumps in one year because the business sold a shop or a piece of land. A one time gain can lift the number for a year, and the next year will show the true rate again. Look for profit that comes from the daily trade, not from selling the furniture. The daily trade is the engine, and the engine must run every year.
Write the five year return for owners beside the rough check of 20 percent, and let the numbers speak. If the business clears the mark in most years, the sixth point is met, and the owners’ money is working well. If it falls far below the mark, ask why, and do not buy until the answer is clear. A rough check is not a verdict, and it is a lamp that lights the next question.
7. Does It Need Little New Money to Grow?
The best businesses grow without asking for much new money, and Buffett has loved this mark for most of his life. A business that can grow its sales while using the same shops, the same machines, and the same small pile of capital is a business that keeps its profit. A business that must pour in fresh money each year to grow is a business that eats its own profit. The less new money a business needs, the more of its profit stays with its owners.
See’s Candies is the clearest example of this mark, and the numbers tell the tale. From 1972 to 2007, the firm sold about 16 million pounds of candy in the first year, and only about twice that much thirty five years later, a rise of only about 2 percent a year. Yet its profit rose by about 9 percent a year over the same years, because it raised prices a little and needed almost no new capital. The growth came from the name and the habit, not from new shops or new machines.
Ask where the growth money goes, and the answer will show the true cost of growth. A business that grows by building new shops each year must spend its profit on bricks and wages. A business that grows by serving the same buyers better can keep its profit and grow at the same time. The first kind of growth is costly, and the second kind is a gift.
Look at the yearly report, and count the money spent on new buildings, machines, and shops. A business that spends most of its profit on such things has little left for its owners. A business that spends only a small share of its profit on such things has much left to share. The share spent on growth is the share that does not reach the owners, so a small share is a good sign.
Beware of a business that grows fast only because it keeps buying other firms. A firm that buys its way to size must pay for each new piece, and the price is often too high. Buffett prefers a business that grows from its own trade, because such growth is earned, not bought. A business that must buy growth is a business that cannot grow on its own.
The mark also guards your own money in a plain way, and the lesson is worth keeping. A business that needs little new money can send its profit to owners year after year, and the owners can use it as they wish. A business that needs much new money must keep its profit, and the owners must wait. Waiting is fine when the growth is real, yet a business that never sends profit home is a business to watch with care.
Write down how much new money the business needed in the last five years, and set it beside its profit. If the new money is a small share of the profit, the seventh point is met, and the business grows the easy way. If the new money eats most of the profit, ask why, and do not buy until the answer is clear. A business that grows on little is a business that can grow for a long time.
8. Are Its Profits Steady Year After Year?
A good business earns well in most years, and its profit does not swing like a wild swing. Buffett looks for demonstrated consistent earning power, and the words mean profit that shows up year after year. A business that earns well in a good year and loses in a bad year is a business at the mercy of the weather. A business that earns well in good years and bad is a business with a strong trade.
Look at the profit of the last ten years, and the line should rise with only small dips. A line that climbs slowly is a sign of a sound business, and a line that jumps up and down is a sign of a shaky one. One bad year can be a passing storm, yet three bad years in a decade are a pattern. A pattern of steady profit is the mark of a business that can be trusted.
A food maker in a small town showed this mark when a hard year struck its whole region. Sales fell for a time, yet the firm still earned a profit, because its buyers kept buying bread and milk each week. Its rivals cut prices and still lost money, while the steady firm held its ground. When the hard year passed, the steady firm was stronger than before, and its rivals were gone.
Ask what makes the profit swing, and the answer will show the risk. A business that depends on one large buyer can lose much when that buyer leaves. A business that depends on the price of one raw material can suffer when that price jumps. A business with many small buyers and steady costs has a profit that rests on many legs, and many legs are hard to break at once.
Beware of profit that is dressed up by clever accounting, because the dress can hide a weak trade. A firm can show a fine profit while its cash stays thin, and the gap is a warning. Buffett reads the cash that a business truly takes in, because cash is harder to dress up than profit. If the cash and the profit do not agree over several years, ask why before you buy.
The table below sets out the four marks from the 1977 letter, and it is the anchor of this whole article. Buffett wrote that he selects stocks in much the same way he would judge a business for purchase in full, and his words were ‘We want the business to be (1) one that we can understand, (2) with favorable long-term prospects, (3) operated by honest and competent people, and (4) available at a very attractive price.’ Each mark is a test, and a business must pass all four before it earns a closer look. Keep the table beside you when you read the other points, because the other points are only a closer look at these four.
| The four marks from the 1977 letter | What each mark means in plain words |
|---|---|
| One that we can understand | You can explain how it earns money |
| Favourable long term prospects | Buyers will still need it in ten years |
| Operated by honest and competent people | Managers you would trust for a decade |
| Available at a very attractive price | The price leaves a wide margin of safety |
Write the ten year profit line in plain numbers before you buy, and keep it where you can see it. A line that rises slowly with small dips is a green light, and a line that swings wildly is a red light. The eighth point is met when the profit shows up year after year, in good times and bad. Steady profit is the quiet proof of a sound business.
9. Is the Price Very Attractive?
The fourth mark in the 1977 letter is a very attractive price, and Buffett has held it as firmly as the other three. He has said that price is what you pay, and value is what you get, and the gap between the two is where profit lives. A wonderful business bought at a wild price can still lose you money, and a fair business bought at a low price can still serve you well. The price matters as much as the quality, and both must be right.
The true worth of a business is the cash it can send to its owners over its whole life, counted back to today. That is the plain meaning of intrinsic value, and it is the number every careful buyer tries to judge. A price below that value leaves a margin of safety, and the margin guards you when your guess is wrong. A price above that value leaves no room for error, and error always comes in time.
Buffett warned in his 1982 letter that a price too high can undo ten years of good business, and the warning is worth keeping. He had watched buyers pay wild prices for fine firms, and the fine firms still lost them money for years. The business was good, yet the price was wrong, and the price was the part that hurt. Quality alone never saves a buyer who pays too much.
Ask how much you would pay for the whole business if you had to own it for life. A buyer who thinks in whole businesses sees the price more clearly than a buyer who thinks in daily price moves. If the whole business is worth 100 million dollars in your plain judgment, and the market asks for 60 million, the gap is your safety. If the market asks for 120 million, the gap is gone, and the wise move is to wait.
Patience is the partner of a good price, and Buffett has waited years for the right one. He keeps a pile of cash ready, and he waits for the market to offer a fine business at a low price. A buyer who must buy today will pay whatever price the day offers, while a buyer who can wait will pay only the price he chooses. The power to wait is the power to buy well.
Beware of the voice that says a great business is worth any price, because the voice is a trap. In his 1989 letter Buffett wrote that it is far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price, and the word fair is the key. Fair means a price that leaves room for error, not a price that asks you to trust in luck. A fair price is a price that lets you sleep well.
Write your own plain value for the business before you look at its market price, and keep the two apart. If the market price sits far below your value, the ninth point is met, and the margin is wide. If the market price sits above your value, walk away with a calm mind, and let the business come to you. The market offers a new price each day, and a patient buyer will see a fair one in time.
10. Be Glad to Own the Whole Business
Buffett selects stocks in much the same way he would judge a business for purchase in full, and those are his own words from the 1977 letter. The test is simple, and it changes how you look at every share. A share is not a ticket in a daily game, and it is a small piece of a real business with real shops, real workers, and real buyers. If you would not own the whole business, you should not own a small piece of it.
A neighbour in my town once bought shares in a firm he had never visited, and he sold them three weeks later at a small loss. He had bought a moving price, not a business, and the price moved against him. A buyer who thinks in whole businesses would have asked if he wanted to own the firm for ten years. The answer would have been no, and the no would have saved him the loss.
Ask if you would be glad to own the whole firm, with all its shops, its workers, and its bills. A glad yes means the business is sound, and the price is the only question left. A doubtful maybe means the business has a fault you have not yet named, and the fault will grow with time. Own only what you would gladly own in full, and the rule will guard you well.
The test also clears the mind of daily noise, because a whole business does not change with each headline. A firm that is sound today is sound tomorrow, even if its price falls by a tenth in a week. Buffett has said he welcomes lower prices for stocks he owns, because a lower price lets him buy more of a good thing at a better price. A buyer who thinks in whole businesses sees a falling price as a gift, not a fear.
Beware of a business you would never buy in full, yet whose shares tempt you with a quick rise. A quick rise is the promise of the daily game, and the daily game is not the game Buffett plays. He holds his best businesses for decades, and he lets the profit pile up in peace. A share bought for a quick rise is a share bought without a reason, and a share without a reason is a loss waiting to happen.
The test works for your own small ventures too, and it works far beyond the market. Before you open a small shop, ask if you would be glad to own the whole street of shops just like it. Before you join a partner, ask if you would be glad to own the whole trade with him for ten years. A glad yes is a green light, and a doubtful maybe is a warning to wait.
Write the answer in one plain sentence before you buy, and keep it honest. The sentence can say that you would gladly own the whole business for ten years, or it can say that you would not. If the sentence is a glad yes, the tenth point is met, and you are thinking like an owner. An owner thinks in decades, and a chaser of daily prices thinks only in days.
11. Explain It in One Short Paragraph
Buffett has said that you only have to be able to judge firms inside your circle of understanding, and the one paragraph test proves it. If you can explain a business in one short paragraph, you understand it well enough to judge it. If you cannot, you do not yet understand it, and the honest move is to learn more or to pass. The paragraph is the proof, and the proof is plain.
Write the paragraph with four plain facts, and leave out every fancy word. Say what the business sells, who buys it, why buyers choose it over rivals, and how it earns its profit. A paragraph that holds those four facts is a paragraph that shows true understanding. A paragraph that hides behind fancy words shows only that the writer is lost.
A teacher in a small town used this test on every firm she owned, and her list stayed short and strong. She could explain each one to her pupils in a minute, and the pupils understood her. When a new firm came to her notice, she tried the paragraph first, and most firms failed it. Her short list beat the long lists of her friends, because every item on it was understood.
Test the paragraph on a friend who knows nothing about the business, and watch his face. If he nods and follows, the paragraph is clear, and your understanding is real. If he frowns and asks twice, the paragraph is cloudy, and your understanding needs more work. A clear mind makes a clear paragraph, and a cloudy mind makes a cloudy one.
Beware of a business that needs a long report to explain, because length often hides a weak trade. A sound business can be told in a few plain lines, while a weak one needs charts, promises, and bright talk. Buffett prefers the plain tale, and he distrusts the tale that needs a show. If the story needs a show, the business may need one too.
The paragraph also guards you when the market turns wild, because a clear idea is a calm anchor. A buyer who knows why he owns a business can hold it through a hard year without fear. A buyer who owns only a story will sell at the first sign of trouble, and the sale will lock in the loss. The paragraph you write today is the courage you will need tomorrow.
Write your paragraph tonight for any business you already own, and keep it beside your list. If the paragraph flows in a few plain lines, the eleventh point is met, and your understanding is sound. If the paragraph stalls, learn more before you buy another share. A paragraph that is clear is a mind that is clear.
12. Does It Treat Its Owners Fairly?
A business has owners, and the owners are the people who hold its shares, small as their pieces may be. Buffett has always treated the owners of Berkshire as partners, and he writes to them as partners each year. A business that treats its owners with fairness will tell them the plain truth, share the profit with care, and spend their money as if it were its own. A business that treats its owners poorly will hide the truth and spend their money on itself.
Look for managers who buy shares with their own money, and hold them for years. A manager who owns a large piece of the business will guard it as his own, because it is his own. A manager who owns almost nothing will guard his pay first, and the business second. Ownership aligns the manager with you, and alignment is the heart of fairness.
Read how the managers speak to owners in the yearly letter, and listen for plain talk. Do they admit mistakes in plain words, or do they dress each fault in smooth talk, and do they explain how they spend the profit, or leave the spending in the dark. A letter that is plain and honest is a good sign, and a letter that is smooth and cloudy is a warning.
Watch what the business does when it has more cash than it needs for good work. A fair business will send the extra cash back to owners, or buy back shares only when the price is low. A careless business will spend the extra cash on grand buys at high prices, and the owners will pay for the grandeur. The use of extra cash is the clearest test of fairness, and the test shows in the numbers.
A shopkeeper in a small town showed this mark when his shop earned more than it needed in a good year. He shared the extra profit with the workers who had earned it, and he set aside a fair share for the lean years ahead. His workers stayed with him for decades, and his shop grew stronger each year. Fairness is not a cost, and it is the seed of loyalty.
Beware of a business that pays its managers far more than the profit can bear, while owners receive little. A manager who takes a grand sum in a poor year has put himself before his owners. Buffett has long favoured pay that is fair and tied to real results, and he distrusts pay that rewards size alone. Fair pay is a sign of fair managers, and fair managers are a sign of a fair business.
Ask if you would trust these managers with your savings for ten years, and let the answer guide you. If the answer is a calm yes, the twelfth point is met, and the owners are treated well. If the answer is doubt, walk away, because no price can make unfair managers safe. Fairness is earned slowly, and it is the mark of a business built to last.
13. Can It Raise Prices Without Losing Buyers?
The power to raise prices is the clearest proof of a strong business, and Buffett has prized it above all other marks. A business that can lift its prices a little each year without losing buyers has a name that buyers love. A business that must cut its prices to keep buyers has no such love, and it fights for each sale. Pricing power is the fruit of trust, and trust is earned over decades.
See’s Candies is the example that taught Buffett this lesson, and the story is worth keeping. The firm raised its prices year after year, and buyers still came back with gifts for their families. The candy was not the cheapest on the shelf, yet it was the one buyers trusted most. That trust let the firm earn more each year while selling only a little more candy.
Ask if the business could raise its prices by a small share tomorrow, and keep most of its buyers. A maker of a loved brand can do it, and a maker of a plain good cannot. The answer shows how much buyers love the name, and love is the true moat. A business with pricing power can outlast hard years, because it can pass its rising costs to buyers who stay.
Look at the price history of the last ten years, and the line should climb slowly. A line that climbs a little each year is a sign of a loved name, and a line that stays flat is a sign of a weak one. A business that cannot lift its prices must earn by selling more, and selling more is a harder road. The slow climb of prices is the quiet proof of a strong business.
Beware of a business that must cut prices to win each new buyer, because the cut eats its profit. A firm that lives on sales and deals is a firm that has no love from its buyers. Buffett prefers a firm that buyers seek out, not a firm that must chase them with a lower price. A buyer who seeks is a buyer who stays, and a buyer who is chased will leave for the next deal.
The power to raise prices also guards the business when costs rise, and the guard is worth much. A maker of food can pass a rise in wheat to buyers who trust its name, while a maker of plain goods must swallow the rise. The first firm keeps its profit, and the second firm loses it. Pricing power is the shield that guards profit in hard years.
Write down the last three price rises of the business, and ask if buyers stayed. If buyers stayed through each rise, the thirteenth point is met, and the business holds real power. If buyers left at the first rise, the power is weak, and the business must earn its keep another way. A name that can lift its price is a name that can lift its owners too.
14. Buy for Years, Not for a Quick Rise
Buffett has said he never tries to buy shares for a short term rise in price, and the words are from the 1977 letter itself. He buys a piece of a business, and he holds it for as long as the business stays excellent. A buyer who thinks in years will judge a business by its profit, while a buyer who thinks in weeks will judge it by its price moves. The first way is the way of an owner, and the second way is the way of a watcher.
The holding period changes every question you ask, and the change is the point, because a buyer who will hold for ten years asks if the business will still earn well in ten years. A buyer who will hold for ten days asks only if the price will rise by Friday. The first question leads to a sound business, and the second question leads to a guess. A guess can win once, yet a sound business can win for decades.
Buffett still holds shares he bought decades ago, and the decades are the proof of his way. He bought Coca-Cola shares in 1988, and he has held them through good years and bad. He bought See’s Candies in 1972, and the firm has served him for more than fifty years. Time is the friend of a wonderful business, and the friend grows kinder with each year.
Ask how long you plan to hold before you buy, and write the number down. A plan to hold for ten years will make you study the business with care. A plan to hold for ten days will make you watch the price with fear. The number you write is the measure of your patience, and patience is the partner of profit.
Beware of the urge to sell when the price falls, because the fall is often the best time to buy more. Buffett has said he welcomes lower prices for stocks he owns, because a lower price lets him buy more of a good thing at a better price. A buyer who thinks in years sees a falling price as a sale, not a scare. A buyer who thinks in days sees a falling price as a reason to run.
The market is a place that offers a new price each day, and the price is only an offer, not a verdict. A sound business does not change its worth because its price moved on a Tuesday. A buyer who knows the worth can smile at the offer and wait for a better one. The offer changes daily, and the worth changes slowly, year by year.
Write your holding plan in one plain line before you buy, and keep it where you can see it. The line can say that you plan to hold for ten years, or for as long as the business stays excellent. If you cannot write such a line, the fourteenth point is not met, and the purchase is a guess. A guess is not a plan, and a plan is what makes an owner.
15. Still Buy If the Market Closed for Ten Years
The last point is the hardest test of all, and it comes from Buffett’s own way of thinking. Imagine the market closed tomorrow for ten years, and no one could buy or sell a single share. Would you still be glad to own this business, with no price to watch and no sale to make. If the answer is yes, you own a business, and if the answer is no, you own only a hope of a higher price.
The test clears away every trace of the daily game, and it leaves only the business itself. A firm that earns well, serves loyal buyers, and is run by honest people will still be glad to own with no market at all. A firm that earns little, serves fickle buyers, and is run by careless people will be a burden with no market to save it. The closed market is the mirror that shows the true worth of a purchase.
A farmer in an old tale bought a small orchard, and he never once asked its price. He asked only if the trees were sound, if the soil was rich, and if the fruit would sell each year. The orchard served him for forty years, and he never needed a market to tell him its worth. A buyer of shares can think the same way, and the orchard is the better model.
Ask if the business would still earn well with no market to cheer it on. A sound trade earns in silence, and it does not need applause to pay its owners. A weak trade earns only when the crowd is kind, and the crowd is kind only in good years. The business that earns in silence is the business worth owning for a decade.
Beware of a purchase that needs a rising market to succeed, because the market will not always rise. A business that must be sold to a greater fool is a business that has no worth of its own. Buffett has always bought worth, not the hope of a higher price from the next buyer. Worth stays when the market closes, and hope fades with the closing bell.
The test also brings peace to the owner, because a business that passes it needs no daily watch. An owner who would gladly hold for ten years with no market can sleep well through any storm. An owner who needs the market open each day will live in fear of each headline. Peace is the fruit of a sound purchase, and the fruit is worth more than gold.
Use this last point as the final gate, and let it judge the fourteen that came before. If the business passes all fifteen points, you have found a rare thing, and the rare thing is worth waiting for. If it fails this last point, pass it over, even if the other fourteen look bright. The checklist points Warren Buffett used before buying any stock end here, and they end with the hardest question of all.
Conclusion
These fifteen points share one plain idea, and that idea is that buying a share means buying a business. The checklist points Warren Buffett used before buying any stock are not an official list he published, and they are a synthesis drawn from his letters, speeches, and interviews. They begin with his own four marks from the 1977 letter, and they grow into a filter any careful buyer can use. A filter that is used daily is a filter that saves a fortune.
The four marks from the 1977 letter are worth keeping in your pocket, because they hold the whole method in a few lines. A business you can understand, with good long term prospects, run by honest and able people, at a very attractive price. Those few words have guided Buffett for nearly fifty years, and they have never needed a change. A method that lasts fifty years is a method worth learning.
I hope you use this checklist on your next purchase, and take it slowly, one point at a time. A business that fails an important point can be passed over, even if its price looks tempting. A business that passes all fifteen is rare, and rare is the reason such a business is worth waiting for. The wait is the hardest part, and the wait is the part that pays.
Your past choices do not decide your future, and your age does not decide it either. Your daily habits decide it, one careful check at a time, and each check is a brick in a wiser life. A buyer who asks the fifteen questions before he buys is a buyer who rarely walks into a trap. The questions are free, and the answers are worth a fortune.
Share this article with a friend who is learning to judge a business, and talk about the fifteen points over a meal. A shared checklist is easier to keep than a lonely one, and a friend who checks with you grows with you. Talk about the one point that helped you most, and ask which one helped him most.
A year from now, the checklist will feel like an old friend, and your choices will show its mark. Keep the habit, keep the questions, and keep the calm that clear thinking brings. The filter grows stronger with each year you use it, and the growth never truly stops.
Tonight, before the day ends, write the four marks from the 1977 letter on a plain card and keep it where you can see it. Read it each morning for a week, and use it on the first business you judge each day. A year from today, you will be glad you started on this very night.
